Evolutionary Biology Spring 2016 Study Questions
Lecture 1 - Jan 19th 2016
1) What type of adaptation would you expect to see in an organism living in an environment with visual predators?
2) What’s one possible explanation for powered flight appearing only once in invertebrates and at least three times in vertebrates?
3) Why would it be advantageous for an organism to resemble something else; i.e. a caterpillar that looks like bird droppings or an orchid that smells like carrion?
4) What’s convergence? Can you think of an example we saw in lecture?
5) Do similar traits always evolve because they solve the same challenges? For instance, are bright colors always favored because of their role in getting a mate?
6) In what ways can humans be a source of selection to other organisms?
7) What’s the difference between evolutionary change and plasticity?
Lecture 2 - Jan 21st 2016
1) What is the difference between genotype and phenotype?
2) How might an organism’s environment influence its phenotype? Think of the examples you saw in lecture and come up with two more.
3) In class, we focused on figuring out how to tell if a phenotypic difference was caused by an evolutionary change. What if there is no phenotypic difference between two populations you observe in the wild? Could there still have been an evolutionary change? Why or why not?
4) In class, we talked about the work of Peter and Rosemary Grant on Galápagos finches. Why were these finches a good system in which to study evolution? Give three reasons.
5) What do you predict would happen to finch bill size after another generation, if the rains return? Explain your answer.
6) Define adaptation/an adaptive trait. What happens to the frequency of adaptive traits over generations?
7) What conditions must be met for evolution by natural selection to take place?
8) Why do we think that the loss of armor in freshwater sticklebacks is adaptive, even though we don’t know how armor loss helps their survival?
9) What is one way that the stickleback and finch examples are similar? What is one way they are different?
Lecture 3 - Jan 26th 2016
1) A trait in certain individuals within a population increases their fitness by 3%, can this trait be considered an adaptation?
2) Why were researchers able to use corn to examine the effects of natural selection? What factors made this a good study system?
3) A scientist is studying mice in meadows and has been able to document fitness levels of different genotypes over many years. If this scientist transplanted these mice to a woodlands environment would you expect to see the same trends in fitness in this new environment? Why or why not?
4) You are studying a rabbit species in which some individuals have brown fur and some have black fur. After performing some crosses you are able to determine that the allele for black fur is dominant. With this information can you conclude then that having black fur makes the rabbits more fit than if they had brown fur?
5) How were researchers able to conclude that apical dominance in corn was not a new mutation caused by domestication?
6) Is there a limit on how many bases must be changed by a mutation before this new mutation can be considered adaptive?
7) What are the different ways in which selection can vary?
8) Are there ways that natural selection could act upon a population without producing an evolutionary response?
Lecture 4 - Jan 28th 2016
1) Why was it important for researchers to understand the life cycle of HIV?
2) What method was used for the first treatment of HIV?
3) How was the virus able to rebound after treatment with AZT?
4) What were some of the factors that we discussed that allows HIV to quickly evolve drug resistance?
5) What do we need to know about a study system in order to conclude whether or not evolution has occurred?
6) Do changes in alleles need to be directional in order to be considered an evolutionary change or can they fluctuate randomly? Explain your answer.
7) When organisms are in a changing environment, what do we need to know in order to conclude that a phenotypic change is a result of evolution rather than plasticity?
8) Explain how treating HIV-infected individuals with multiple drugs slows down the evolution of drug resistance. What else can we attempt to slow down the evolution of resistance?
Lecture 5 - Feb 2nd 2016
1) Explain the differences between Mendelian and quantitative traits, and give an example for each.
2) Why can’t we perfectly predict phenotype from genotype for quantitative traits?
3) Fur color in mice depends primarily on the genetic composition at five different loci (A-E). Suppose that each locus has two alleles, and that one of the alleles (called A1-E1) makes fur lighter while the other allele (called A2-E2) makes fur darker. As a result, mice that possess 10 '2' alleles are jet black while those that possess 10 '1' alleles are white.
- A. How many different fur color phenotypes are there (ignoring environmental effects)?
- B. How many different genotypes are there?
- C. How many different genotypes produce the phenotype that is one shade lighter than jet black? (Hint: think about how many different places a '1' allele could occur)
4) Explain what is wrong with the following statement: “Heritability indicates the degree to which a trait is genetic. Traits with high heritability are genetically determined, while those with low heritability are environmentally determined.” Give an example (real or hypothetical) in which a trait is genetically determined, but the heritability is low (or zero).
5) Provide the name and meaning for each term of the following equation: R = h2 * S.
6) How is heritability defined? How can heritability be measured?
7) The slope of the regression line describing the relationship between the number of abdominal bristles in offspring and the number of abdominal bristles in parents is 0.63 in a laboratory population of Drosophila melanogaster.
- A. What is the heritability of abdominal bristle number in this population?
- B. Suppose that the mean abdominal bristle number in this strain is 237 and suppose that a population geneticist imposes selection on bristle number so that the mean abdominal bristle number among those allowed to reproduce is 196. What will the mean abdominal bristle number among the offspring be?
8) Why is heritability dependent on the environment in which it's measured?
9) How are natural selection and sexual selection similar? How are they different?
Lecture 6 - Feb 4th 2016
1) What is the key difference between the “good genes” hypothesis and the runaway sexual selection model?
2) What does it mean to say that male ornamentation and female choosiness are genetically correlated?
3) In pipefish, females transfer their eggs to males, who then fertilize, carry, and care for them. Which sex would you predict is the choosy sex? Which sex probably participates in intrasexual selection? Why?
4) Why do males typically have more variability in their reproductive success compared to females?
5) Peacocks with a large number of eyespots on their tails attract more mates than those with few eyespots. Design an experiment to test whether the number of eyespots in a male’s tail is a signal of his genetic quality (aka how would you test the “good genes” hypothesis in this system?).
6) Does natural selection always oppose sexual selection? Explain your answer.
7) What is the relationship between population genetics and Mendelian genetics?
8) In a population of 550 plants, a single gene (DFR) controls flower color. There are 222 homozygous dominant (DFR/DFR) individuals, 150 homozygous recessive individuals (dfr/dfr), and 178 heterozygotes (DFR/dfr). What is the frequency of the dfr allele in this population?
Lecture 7 - Feb 9th 2016
1) A population contains the alleles D and d. The frequency of D is 0.6 and the frequency of d is 0.4. If individuals mate at random within the population what is the chance that an offspring will have the genotype Dd?
2) What happens to genotype frequencies in a population under Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium in subsequent generations? What happens to allele frequencies?
3) You observe the genotype frequencies of a cow population for 2 generations. The allele frequencies and genotype frequencies do not change. Is this population in HWE? Why or why not.
4) Today we discussed several factors that could have caused a difference between the observed genotype frequencies and the frequencies expected under Hardy-Weinberg Equilibrium within sample 2 from our activity. What were some of those factors?
5) If you observe no change in genotype/allele frequencies between two generations can you conclude that nothing is influencing the population?
6) In a population of 100,000 flour beetles there exists a recessive genetic disease that causes antennae to develop in a “Z” shape when in the homozygous condition. You find 10 individuals with Z-shaped antennae. Calculate the genotype and allele frequencies for this population of flour beetles. Assume that the population is in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium.
7) Explain why there was an increase in the heterozygote genotype frequencies within the older generation sample (sample 2) in Activity 4.
8) How many generations does it take for a population to establish genotype frequencies in HWE (Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium) given all the assumptions are met?
9) Hardy-Weinberg practice: The major histocompatibility complex (MHC) consists of a suite of genes that play an important role in the immune system. While studying a particular MHC locus in a population of deer found in Connecticut, you discover ample genetic variation. There appears to be two common alleles residing at this particular MHC locus. You characterize the genotype of 200 individuals from this population. You discover 40 individuals with genotype AA, 130 individuals with genotype AB, and 30 individuals with genotype BB. (a) What are the genotype frequencies of the sample population of deer?
(b) What are the allele frequencies?
(c) Given the allele frequencies, what are the expected Hardy-Weinberg genotype frequencies?
(d) Is the population in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium with respect to the AB MHC locus?
10) Hardy-Weinberg practice: Consider the following pair of subpopulations of a tropical butterfly, with genotype frequencies as shown:
Three biologists head to the field to collect this species, and each ends of collecting 500 individuals.
The first biologist gets altitude sickness easily, so he samples only individuals from the lowlands.
(a) What allele frequencies does the first biologist find (assuming he has a random sample of the population)?
(b) What are the expected genotype frequencies assuming Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium?
(c) How do the observed genotype frequencies compare to the expected frequencies?
The second biologist hates the heat, so she drives up the mountain and samples only individuals from the top.
(d) What allele frequencies does the second biologist find?
e) What are the expected genotype frequencies assuming Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium?
(f) How do the observed genotype frequencies compare to the expected frequencies?
The third biologist is a bit more adventurous, and samples individuals continuously as she hikes up the mountain. Assume that she ends up sampling an equal number from the lowland and mountain top populations.
(g) What are the observed genotype frequencies in the sample obtained by the third biologist?
(h) What are the allele frequencies in this sample?
(i) What are the expected genotype frequencies assuming Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium?
(j) Which genotype(s) is overrepresented in the observed sample compared to the expected sample? Which is underrepresented?
(k)What would the third biologist conclude about Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium?
(l) What assumption that we used in deriving the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium is violated in this case?
Lecture 8 - Feb 11th 2016
1) What are the four assumptions of the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium?
2) A population contains individuals that display three genotypes: QQ, Qq, and qq. QQ has a frequency of 0.3, Qq has a frequency of 0.45, and qq has a frequency of 0.25. What is the mating frequency between a QQ and Qq mating pair?
3) In a population it has been found that 1 in 10,000 individuals displays albinism, a recessive condition that causes pale skin and white hair. What is the frequency of carriers of the albinism gene within the population?
4) What HWE assumption does natural selection violate?
5) A population of 100 guppies displays three genotypes: AA, AB, and BB. There are 30 AA individuals, 40 AB individuals, and 30 BB individuals.
a.Calculate the genotype frequencies.
b.Calculate the allele frequencies.
c.The probability of survival for the AA genotype is 0.3, for the AB genotype is 0.9, and for the BB genotype is 0.6. Calculate the mean fitness of the population.
d. What is the frequency of each genotype after selection?
6) An allele in a species of flowers controls stamen length. Individuals with TT have long stamens, tt individuals have short stamens, and Tt individuals display an intermediate length. A researcher surveys a population of 500 flowers and finds that 240 individuals have long stamens, 150 have intermediate stamens, and 110 have short stamens.
a. What are the genotype frequencies?
b. What are the allele frequencies?
7) Imagine that the frequency of allele D is 0.7 in a set of zygotes that you sample. All DD and Dd individuals survive to reproduce, but only 60% of dd individuals survive to reproduce.
a. What is the average fitness of the population in this generation?
b. What will be the frequencies of D and d alleles in the zygotes of the next generation (assuming mating is random and drift has no effect)
c. What will the frequencies of the D and d alleles be in the adults of the next generation?
d. What is the average fitness of the population in this next generation?
8) The fur length of a species of mice is controlled by two alleles: L and S. The observed genotype frequencies are 0.75 for LL, 0.1 for LS, and 0.15 for SS.
a. What would the mating frequency be for a LS and LS mating pair? What proportion of their offspring might be LL?
b. What would the mating frequency be for a SS and LL mating pair? What proportion of their offspring might be LS?
9) At birth the frequency of allele B is 0.45. About 80% of BB individuals survive to reproduce while only 50% of Bb and bb individuals survive to reproduce.
a. What are the genotype and allele frequencies of this generation at birth?
b. What is the mean fitness of the population?
c. What are the genotype frequencies of the adults?
d. What genotype frequencies would you expect the next generation to have at birth?
10) What HWE assumption does mutation violate?
Lecture 9 - Feb 16th 2016
1. What does it mean when an allele has “been fixed” or “gone to fixation” in a population?
2. Fill in the following table:
|Type of selection||Maintains or eliminates genetic variation?||Highest fitness genotype(s)||Initial allele frequency important?||Consequences|
3. What are fitness landscapes? Why are they parabolic?
4. Butterflies that are palatable (tasty to insectivores) often develop patterns mimicking poisonous butterflies to avoid predation. Let’s say a population of palatable butterflies develops two kinds of wing patterns, each looking like a different species of poisonous butterfly. Assume that the mating between two butterflies of different wing patterns produces a heterozygote that doesn’t look poisonous to predators. What kind of selection (balancing/directional/disruptive) would act on this population? How do you know?
5. In a population of 1000 plants, there are two alleles for petal spots: P1 (purple spots) and P2 (no spots). 200 plants have the genotype P1P1, 350 are P2P2, and 450 are P1P2. The fitness of each genotype is as follows: w11=0.7, w22=0.9, and w12=1. What is the mean fitness of this population?
6. From Fisher’s Fundamental Theorem, we know that offspring are more fit than their parents if we make one important assumption. What do we assume, and why?
7. Why can’t we say that balancing selection maximizes the number of heterozygote individuals in a population?
8. Why might balancing selection be more prevalent in the short term than the long term? Use a specific example, real or hypothetical, to support your answer.
9. Why does it take longer (more generations) to fix alleles when fitness differences are very small?
10. Why do we say that the outcome of genetic drift (fixation of one allele) is not predictable?
11. We have already talked about genetic differences that are considered neutral. Can you think of an example of a neutral phenotypic difference?
Lecture 10 - Feb 18th 2016
1. Why can’t we assume that all “functionless” traits (e.g. eye genes in cave fish) are neutral?
2. Which is more likely to be neutral: a non-coding region of the genome, or a protein coding gene? Why?
3. Define and distinguish genetic drift and random sampling error.
4. As you increase sampling (for example, flip a coin 200 times versus 10 times), does the expected outcome occur more or less frequently? Do the extreme rare outcomes occur more or less frequently?
5. Can genetic drift and selection occur simultaneously? Explain your answer.
6. Consider two populations of plants, each with the same two alleles for height: T and t. Assume that there are no fitness differences between TT, Tt, and tt genotypes. Population 1 consists of 10 individuals, while Population 2 has 1000. The frequency of the T allele in both populations starts at 0.7.
- A. In which population will the effects of genetic drift be stronger? Why?
- B. Are these populations more likely to fix the T allele or the t allele? Why?
- C. After 10 generations, researchers discover that the t allele has been fixed in Population 1. Is this result surprising? Why or why not?
7. Explain why genetic drift reduces genetic diversity within a population, but increases genetic diversity between populations.
8. A researcher encounters a small island population of birds, which has been fixed for an allele producing white feather color. On the mainland, the white feather allele occurs at a low frequency (0.1) because it increases predation. The island has no mainland predators.
- A. Give one explanation for the fixation of the white allele on the island that involves natural selection.
- B. Give one explanation for the fixation of the white allele on the island that involves genetic drift.
- C. How could the researcher test whether natural selection or genetic drift was a better mechanism for the fixation of the white allele? Hint: Consider how each of these phenomena operates on the whole genome.
9. How are bottlenecks and the founder effect similar? How are they different?